In my CotMA game, I use minis. I make no bones about the fact that I like them.
I also like battlemats and dungeon tiles. The problem with the battlemats and dungeon tiles are the SQUARES. It's very easy to get hung up on the 5' squares. I'm sure we can get past it, but in the interest of trying something out, we skipped the squares and used Jenga blocks for the dungeon walls in our most recent adventure.
I've posted about making my own battlemats before. I have a "battlemat" that I used years ago when I ran a FATE game. Combat is very abstract in FATE, but I still wanted some kind of representation. Basically, my FATE battlemat is a large piece of white vinyl with no markings. You can write on it with wet erase markers, but there are no squares or hexes. I put this down in case we needed to draw something and to protect the table from all the rolling dice.
It turns out that there are some advantages to using Jenga blocks for mapping.
- First, each block is about 10' in scale. That makes scaling the map easy.
- Second, you can just rearrange the blocks AROUND THE MINIS! This was kind of a revelation. When you use a battlemat with drawn walls/rooms, you have to move the minis off the map, spray it with water, wipe it down and then move them all back. When you use Jenga blocks, you just move the walls. The minis stay put. You can then just adjust the placement of the minis to restore the marching order, etc.
- Of course, the Jenga blocks can't form just any shape. You can't easily make a cavern with the detail you could draw with a marker. I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing, the battlemat and minis are supposed to be an abstraction of the reality of the fantasy environment. (Did I just blow your mind there?) I actually like the "chunky" nature of how the walls fit together.
Overall, the reception to the Jenga blocks was positive at the end. I think we'll keep using them for awhile and see how their use holds up over time.
Here are a couple of "re-created" pics to show how the blocks look in play.
The rogue has found a pivoting secret door that opened to reveal a dark altar...
Also, in the TV series, FREAKS AND GEEKS, the characters play a game of Dungeons and Dragons. You can plainly see in these screencaps that the DM is using dominoes to represent the dungeon. I hear that this was common back in the day, but we never did it. Dominoes might be a little easy to tip over in use, but maybe not.
Here's the segment of the episode that includes the adventure. Enjoy!